Trang chủDomestic FootballHanoi FC 2-1 CAHN: When Kewell Abandoned His Philosophy to Keep the Derby, and Polking Signed His Own Verdict With Fitness Talk

Hanoi FC 2-1 CAHN: When Kewell Abandoned His Philosophy to Keep the Derby, and Polking Signed His Own Verdict With Fitness Talk

Core answer: Hanoi FC beat CAHN 2-1 in the V.League round 4 derby on 18 October by abandoning short build-up for long-ball play, with Xuan Manh opening and Van Tung sealing the result after CAHN equalised in the 46th minute. Key facts: - Harry Kewell stated Hanoi FC avoided short passes because CAHN pressed effectively, choosing long balls instead. - Van Tung scored the decisive goal; Kewell described him as strong and a good finisher, making direct play viable. - CAHN equalised in the first minute of the second half before conceding after a defensive lapse. - Polking cited insufficient aggression and a dense schedule affecting player fitness after CAHN lost top spot to Ninh Binh. - Neither coach referenced refereeing or VAR, indicating no officiating controversy in the derby. Source attribution: Match report and post-match press conference quotations, published 18 October (V.League round 4) | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Why did Hanoi FC abandon their possession philosophy against CAHN? A: Kewell said CAHN pressed well, so Hanoi FC deliberately limited short passes that risked turnovers and used long balls to bypass the press. Q: Did CAHN lose top spot in the V.League table after this defeat? A: Yes, CAHN dropped from first place to behind Ninh Binh following their first defeat of the season after three straight wins. Q: Is CAHN's defeat a sign of structural decline? A: No, it is a variance event within four rounds; Polking's own framing of a concentration lapse and fixture congestion points to transient rather than structural causes.

In the first half, I sat in Stand B and counted Hanoi FC's short passes. Not because I enjoy counting. I counted because in the opening fifteen minutes, the sound of footsteps on the pitch rang strangely — it was not the sound of a team holding the ball, but the sound of a team running from itself. The ball went up. The ball came down. And each time, the stadium held its breath.

That was the moment I understood: Harry Kewell did not step onto the pitch to play the football he had always declared. He stepped onto the pitch to survive.

The context of this derby is not in the 2-1 scoreline, but in how it was manufactured.

V.League is at round 4, a round where every conclusion is a rushed conclusion. The derby between Hanoi FC and CAHN — two city rivals, two opposing ownership models, two different pressure tiers — is always the most commercially valued fixture in Vietnamese football. CAHN entered as defending champion, on a three-match winning streak, with a Brazilian head coach, Polking, who had built a pressing framework uncomfortable enough to turn any opponent into a hostage.

Hanoi FC entered with an Australian head coach, an identity under construction, and a promise of controlled football.

Hanoi FC 2-1 CAHN: When Kewell Abandoned His Philosophy to Keep the Derby, and Polking Signed His Own Verdict With Fitness Talk

For the first forty-five minutes, that promise was shattered.

Tactical analysis: no data, but truth nonetheless.

I must say one thing that most match reports will skip: this match had no xG, no PPDA, no published pass-completion figures. Every tactical claim below is therefore qualitative, extracted from direct observation and from the two coaches' own post-match statements — not from a data table.

Kewell said after the match — and this is a rare candid line in a derby press conference: "We wanted to play according to our philosophy, but we also had to base our choices on the opponent… CAHN pressed well, so Hanoi FC played long balls and limited short passes that led to losing the ball."

Read that slowly. A coach admitting that his default build-up system is fragile under coordinated pressing. That is not a compliment to CAHN. It is the confession of a strategist who sees a structural weakness in his own construction — and accepts it against an opponent good enough to exploit it.

Hanoi's chain in this match can be compressed into four steps: long ball to bypass the press → physical duel with Van Tung in the second line → second-ball control → finish. Van Tung's goal is the direct consequence of that chain, not a random moment. Kewell described Van Tung with two words: "strong and finishes well" — the classic target-man profile in modern football. Without Van Tung, this brand of football has no outlet.

Contrarian angle: CAHN did not lose because of tactics; CAHN lost because they tore their own match apart.

First minute of the second half, CAHN equalised. Remember that. A team that equalises in the first minute after the break means they executed the interval instruction. They had found their rhythm. They had caught Hanoi FC in its most confused state.

And then they conceded again.

Polking called it "a lapse in concentration in the defense". He also said the team "played without enough aggression" and that "the dense schedule affected the players' fitness". Three sentences, three different subjects. Loss of concentration is an individual error. Lack of aggression is a collective error. Dense schedule is the organiser's error.

Not one sentence says CAHN were controlled tactically.

That is the familiar reflex of defending champions: when they win, structure is praised; when they lose, fitness and concentration are offered as shields. I have watched football long enough to know that a team that has just equalised and then concedes again has a problem not of structure but of mentality and game-state management. That is a problem for the man holding the clipboard, not for the fixture list.

Hanoi FC 2-1 CAHN: When Kewell Abandoned His Philosophy to Keep the Derby, and Polking Signed His Own Verdict With Fitness Talk

Counter-rhythm: there is a story neither coach wanted to tell.

Xuan Manh's opening goal — a wide player or full-back scoring the opener — is a tactical signal worth far more than what the match report will record. It did not come from central combination play. It came from a wide entry, or from a set piece. For a team that had just abandoned short passing, scoring that way is systematic, not lucky.

Hanoi FC 2-1 CAHN: When Kewell Abandoned His Philosophy to Keep the Derby, and Polking Signed His Own Verdict With Fitness Talk

And there is a detail overlooked across the entire press conference: neither coach mentioned the referee. No VAR. No penalty. No argument. In a tense V.League derby — where officiating is usually dragged out after any unfavourable result — this silence is a rare mature signal. Both sides chose to take responsibility. That deserves credit, even when Polking chose a more diplomatic way of deflecting.

Looking up the table: round 4 is not a season.

CAHN surrendered top spot to Ninh Binh. The press will call it a shock. I call it arithmetic. Four rounds, three wins then one home defeat against a highly motivated rival — that is variance within the normal band of a championship-calibre squad. Ninh Binh leading after four rounds is a fixture-order artefact, a historical phenomenon in Vietnamese football: the early leader is not the champion, and nobody knows who is genuinely strong until round twelve.

My confidence in CAHN has not shifted because of this match. My confidence in CAHN's defensive resilience has.

Hanoi FC won, but they won by denying themselves.

That is what Kewell did not say but everyone saw: a club building an identity had to abandon that identity to win the biggest match of its season so far. In points terms, it was the right call. In strategic terms, it is a small red flag — because the 'long ball against the press' tactic only works against an opponent that presses. Facing a low-block side, playing long, with Van Tung isolated between two centre-backs, Hanoi FC will need another plan. That plan has not appeared in any description of this team.

After the match, Kewell immediately looked toward SHB Da Nang and spoke of 'one match at a time'. That is the standard script of a coach who knows a derby win does not save a season. And it is also the script of a man who knows the goodwill from this victory will last only three to five matches.

What I take away from this match is not the scoreline, but a question about identity.

A club that has spent sixteen years building the best academy in Vietnam, currently owning young players that Japanese, Korean and Thai clubs regularly monitor — where is that club in its journey to find itself again? The win over CAHN does not answer that question. It only proves that a good coach can put tactics above philosophy when necessary.

And sometimes, that very moment is when a true identity is built from the ashes of the old one.

The beat keeper does not seek the spotlight; they wait where the ball rolls. In this derby the ball rolled toward Stand B, toward those who had sat long enough to see a team change shape within forty-five minutes. And perhaps, after all, that is what football truly is: not a declared philosophy, but a decision made in silence, amid the sighs of ten thousand people.

The mistake of 2026 taught me this: the real match begins after the cameras go off. This derby began before the ball rolled — in Kewell's analysis room, where he had to choose between the person he wanted to be and the winner he needed to be.

He chose correctly. But the price of that correctness will only be paid on another day — when the ball no longer flies long, and Van Tung is no longer there.

Cầu thủ liên quan