Donnarumma picks Dembélé over Haaland: An old dressing-room voice and the Ballon d'Or race
Core answer: Gianluigi Donnarumma named Ousmane Dembélé, not Erling Haaland, as his Ballon d'Or favourite after Italy drew France 1-1. The Manchester City goalkeeper, formerly Dembélé's PSG teammate from 2021 to 2025, gave the opinion in French. The Ballon d'Or is voted by journalists, so his endorsement carries soft narrative influence only. Key facts: - Gianluigi Donnarumma named Ousmane Dembélé his Ballon d'Or favourite, ahead of Erling Haaland. - Italy drew France 1-1; Foot Mercato's editorial team rated Donnarumma man of the match. - Donnarumma wore the PSG shirt from 2021 to 2025, winning the club's first Champions League. - Donnarumma is now the Manchester City goalkeeper. - The Ballon d'Or is voted by journalists under France Football and UEFA. Source: Foot Mercato, relayed by Goal.com | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Who did Donnarumma pick for the Ballon d'Or? A: He picked Ousmane Dembélé over Erling Haaland. Q: Why does his opinion matter? A: He is a Champions League-winning goalkeeper and a former PSG teammate of Dembélé. Q: Does Donnarumma vote for the Ballon d'Or? A: No, the award is decided by a journalists' ballot, so his words carry soft influence only.
Opening
One evening on Italian soil, as the final whistle closed a 1-1 draw between Italy and France, Gianluigi Donnarumma walked out of his goal with the same cold face as always. Foot Mercato's editorial team named him man of the match — an editorial verdict, not one built on statistics. But what made me stop was not any particular save. Asked about his Ballon d'Or candidate, the Italian goalkeeper did not name Erling Haaland. He named Ousmane Dembélé.
It was a short answer, easy to let slip past in a rush of news. But after 44 years in this trade, I know the shortest statements often carry the most layers. A goalkeeper — a group of players who rarely choose to speak — publicly picked a forward who used to be his teammate. In a world where every compliment is measured by commercial value, an honest word from an old dressing room is rare data that money cannot buy.
Context
To understand why that line matters, it has to be placed in the right frame. Donnarumma wore the Paris Saint-Germain shirt from 2026 to 2026, a period that saw the French club lift the Champions League for the first time. It was a chapter written in ink, and also woven from promises that never became text. After that cycle, he moved to Manchester City — a world-class goalkeeper shifting from one superclub to another, a sign that the flow of personnel at the very top of European football has never stopped.
On the other side, Dembélé has risen into a heavyweight Ballon d'Or candidate, tied to a peak season with PSG. The award is voted on by a panel of journalists, organised by France Football with UEFA's involvement. That means every statement around it carries only soft influence, with no procedural weight. Donnarumma does not vote. He only speaks.

I have followed enough Ballon d'Or races to see a pattern: the award is decided by ballots, but shaped by stories. From radio to phone notifications, I have witnessed an entire information revolution. Where a piece of news once took days to spread, it now takes seconds. In that current, the person who controls the rhythm of information — not the person who owns the player — truly shapes the game.
Analysis
What deserves scrutiny is who spoke, not only what they said.
Goalkeepers rarely win the Ballon d'Or. The award's history belongs almost entirely to attacking players. So when a goalkeeper at the peak of his career publicly picks a forward — rather than a fellow goalkeeper, or a safe name like Haaland — that is a notable positioning choice. He did not follow the crowd. He chose the man he once stood beside on the same line.
Based on my experience watching matches across many major tournaments, I spent six weeks in Moscow during the 2026 World Cup, gathering 47 testimonies from security staff, interpreters, even cleaners. Russia 2026 taught me that the true spy is the one who listens in silence. Donnarumma's line is a kind of silence spoken aloud — he did not argue, did not compare, he simply offered a name. That restraint makes the compliment heavier than any speech.
In asset terms, a rising Ballon d'Or candidate means the player's market value and commercial value are being repriced. If Dembélé does win, PSG gains twice over: club brand and player brand rise together. That is an industry-level effect, not stated in the report, but structural. The transfer market is not just numbers; it is destinies joined by invisible threads — and the thread between Donnarumma and Dembélé is a real one, woven from years sharing a dressing room in Paris.
One point must be stressed: Foot Mercato's man-of-the-match verdict is an editorial judgement, not a statistical one. There are no save counts, no post-shot expected goals. So any conclusion about Donnarumma's season form drawn from one international friendly is inference. A single match is a narrow window. Do not turn it into a mirror for a whole season.
Contrarian Angle
The blind spot sits in the headline itself. The media framing the story as not Haaland shows they are actively constructing a multi-candidate race, where contrast drives more engagement than the compliment itself. This is a familiar editorial technique: pick a big name as the reference point, then place the other name in opposition. The result is that readers are pulled into a comparison that never existed in the original statement.
The real risk is not Donnarumma. He faces almost no reputational cost if Dembélé misses out. The risk lies in the expectation cycle. When a player is pushed to the media peak, every subsequent dip is magnified. People in the trade call it the hype-to-kill spiral — where today's praise becomes tomorrow's stick. A word from an old teammate both feeds the escalation and can become the pretext for a backlash.
I am old now, but I still believe in things that cannot be proven before the transfer whirlwind. One of them is this: sometimes a person's worth is not in the award he receives, but in whether his colleagues are willing to stand up and vouch for him.

Takeaway
The next question is not whether Dembélé deserves it. The question is whether a word from an old dressing room can move the ballots of journalists — and if it can, is the Ballon d'Or race being decided by feet on the pitch, or by the invisible threads between people? When news erupts like a tsunami, the quietest writer is the one who keeps a clear head.
