Trang chủInternational FootballMakkelie, VAR and the 'clear and obvious' line in Feyenoord vs AZ

Makkelie, VAR and the 'clear and obvious' line in Feyenoord vs AZ

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi**: Theo giao thức VAR của IFAB mà KNVB áp dụng, quyết định của Danny Makkelie chỉ bị đảo ngược nếu VAR chứng minh được 'lỗi rõ ràng và hiển nhiên'. Tranh cãi xoay quanh việc Erwin Blank có vượt ngưỡng can thiệp hay không, chứ không phải về việc luật viết gì. **Dữ kiện chính**: - Phút cuối hiệp một, Feyenoord dẫn AZ 1-0; Makkelie thổi phạt đền cho AZ sau pha ngã của Mexx Meerdink. - VAR Erwin Blank đề nghị Makkelie ra màn hình; quyết định phạt đền bị đảo ngược. - KNVB áp dụng giao thức VAR của IFAB: chỉ can thiệp khi có 'lỗi rõ ràng và hiển nhiên'. - Kees Kwakman nói phạt đền nên giữ nguyên; Been nói hơn 20 lần xem lại không thấy lỗi. - Một bên nhắc tới 52 lần xem lại, dấu hiệu pha bóng không hề rõ ràng. **Nguồn**: Goal.com, bài 'Does Danny Makkelie make a major blunder in Feyenoord v AZ? This is what the rules say', ngày 14 tháng 2 năm 2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan**: - Hỏi: VAR có được phép can thiệp khi quyết định chỉ gây tranh cãi? Đáp: Không; theo giao thức IFAB, nếu quyết định có thể tranh cãi nhưng không sai rõ ràng, quyết định gốc phải được giữ nguyên. - Hỏi: Ai là trọng tài VAR trong trận Feyenoord - AZ? Đáp: Erwin Blank, với Danny Makkelie là trọng tài chính trên sân. - Hỏi: Vì sao số lần xem lại được nhắc tới nhiều? Đáp: Vì nếu cần hơn 50 lần xem lại để kết luận, lỗi khó có thể được coi là 'rõ ràng và hiển nhiên'.

I remember standing up from my chair just as the referee turned and walked toward the monitor by the touchline. Not out of curiosity. This trade taught me that the heaviest decisions are usually made in silence, not in the roar of the stands. Feyenoord were leading AZ 1-0 in an Eredivisie match, and the game was sliding into the final minutes of the first half. Then a backpass shorter than it needed to be. Gjivai Zechiel played it, Tjark Ernst rushed out to put out the fire, and Mexx Meerdink slipped in between the two of them. The attacker went down. The whistle blew. A penalty.

Then the earpiece crackled. Erwin Blank, the VAR, said something to Danny Makkelie. And Makkelie, a man who has refereed the biggest matches in Europe, ran to the monitor, stood there, rewinding and rewinding. The whole stadium held its breath. I held mine too, thousands of kilometres away, in a rented flat in London, under a yellow lamp and beside a coffee gone cold long ago.

The moment a referee stands before a screen, reviewing a passage of play that has already passed, is the strangest moment in modern football. It is at once public and lonely. At once transparent and mysterious. And in this particular case, it brushed against a line that all of European football has not yet finished drawing: where is the point at which a decision becomes 'clearly wrong' enough to be overturned?

We hunt the news all day, but in the end it is the news that hunts us. That night, the news hunted me with a simple question no one answered in full: was Makkelie wrong, or was the very measure he was forced to use the thing that was wrong?

Feyenoord hosting AZ was no qualifier. In the Netherlands, this is a meeting between two of the most familiar forces in the top flight. In recent seasons, PSV has usually been the benchmark at the front, Feyenoord the most persistent challenger, and AZ a recurring name in the European-qualification pack. When two such sides meet, every refereeing decision is magnified many times over compared with an ordinary match. A point can be the difference between the title and second place. A penalty can be the difference between a Champions League place and a Europa League place.

I have followed Dutch football long enough to understand that the Eredivisie is an exporting league. This is where young talents are polished and then sold to the five biggest leagues in Europe. Feyenoord and AZ operate on that model: discover, develop, then transfer. That model also means every big match, every televised moment, is a shop window. And every controversial decision carries a reach that stretches beyond the borders of the Netherlands.

Before going into the detail, I need to be clear about one thing regarding myself. I was not at De Kuip. I have no access to the original VAR footage, and I did not hear the full exchange between Makkelie and Blank. What I have is exactly what the audience has: television pictures, slow-motion angles, and the voices from the studio. But sometimes, sitting in the audience's seat is precisely what lets you see what those inside the room miss. In the summer of 2026, I had no recorder, only a blog and a certain recklessness. That was when I learned that the truth does not lie in what people say on television, but in the numbers and timelines that can be verified.

And here is what can be verified.

First, the law. The Royal Dutch Football Association (KNVB) applies the IFAB VAR protocol verbatim, IFAB being the body that governs the international laws of the game. This protocol sets a very high intervention threshold. VAR may intervene in only two situations: a 'clear and obvious error', or a 'serious missed incident'. The most important operating principle sits right here: if the on-field referee's decision is debatable but not clearly wrong, then the original decision stands as a matter of course.

That is why the story at Feyenoord - AZ is not simply about whether Makkelie was right or wrong. It is about whether the intervention threshold was crossed.

The two lines of opinion in the ESPN studio on the programme 'De Eretribune' stand in sharp opposition. Kees Kwakman argues the penalty should have stood, because there was contact on the foot and the 'clear error' threshold was never touched. On the other side, Been argues it was not a penalty, because more than twenty replays still failed to show any clear foul.

What is notable is that both men, though on opposite sides, accept the law. They do not argue about what the law says. They argue about whether this passage of play reached the threshold. This is a debate about a threshold, not about a fact.

And there is one detail I consider the most important in the whole story, yet it drowns amid the noise: the number of replays. One side mentions more than twenty. One side mentions fifty-two. If it truly took fifty-two viewings to reach a conclusion, then that number betrays itself. A clear and obvious error does not need fifty-two replays; it needs one. If so much rewinding is required, then most likely this was a debatable passage of play, and under the protocol it must stand.

There is another sign, subtler still. Makkelie spent a long stretch at the monitor. No one in the studio knew exactly how long, but the very fact that they questioned the length of time said something. For a clear error, a referee usually needs only a few seconds. For a passage of play sitting right on the edge of the threshold, one stands longer. That hesitation, in itself, is a signal.

And here is the core point regarding responsibility. When Blank called Makkelie to the monitor, he was implicitly declaring that the original decision was a clear error. He must have been fully convinced that it was absolutely not a penalty. The protocol places an almost absolute burden on the VAR: to intervene, you must be nearly certain the referee was wrong. Not 'possibly wrong'. Not 'in doubt'. But 'clearly wrong'.

In the IFAB protocol, besides a 'clear and obvious error', there is a second case that permits VAR intervention: a 'serious missed incident'. But that is a category reserved for events the referee entirely failed to see, such as an off-the-ball punch outside his field of view. A penalty involving debatable contact does not fall into that category. Makkelie saw the passage of play, he blew his whistle, and his decision was not an oversight. So the only door for Blank to walk through was the door marked 'clear and obvious error'. And that is precisely the narrowest door in the whole protocol.

Across many years of watching matches with VAR, I have noticed a repeating pattern. Penalty incidents with subjective contact, a light touch on the foot, a fall at high speed, a blocked angle, are exactly the kind of situation where the 'clear and obvious' threshold must be applied most strictly. Yet it is also in exactly this kind of situation that VAR is most prone to overstepping the threshold. Because when you see a player go down and one foot touch another in slow motion, it is very hard to stay objective about whether the error was truly clear. Slow motion makes every contact look heavier than it was. It turns a fleeting touch into a nudge, and a nudge into a shove.

Here, the passage of play that started it all is worth reading closely too. A short backpass, a goalkeeper rushing out, a forward slipping in between. This is the textbook output of a pressing trap: the opponent hunting the ball in your defensive third, and the instant they win it, attacking the chaos they have just created. The mistake lay in the pass, not in the referee's decision. But when the ball reached the forward's feet and he went down, the story was pushed onto another stage, where the referee becomes the protagonist. And when there is genuine contact, however slight, everything turns murky.

I want to say this plainly, because I have learned that neutrality sometimes demands you choose a side of the truth. If there was contact, and Kwakman believes there was, then the correct outcome under the protocol was most likely to let the on-field penalty stand. That would mean the VAR may have exceeded the intervention threshold. I do not have the original footage to assert this, so I leave it as a grounded hypothesis, not a verdict.

But if we stop at judging whether Makkelie was right or wrong, we miss the bigger story. The real problem does not lie with an individual referee. It lies in the mechanism for summoning referees to the monitor.

Look at what is unusual about the public-opinion pressure in this match. Normally, after a big game, the pressure falls on the clubs: the manager, the players, the board. But here, the pressure falls on the officiating team. Not Feyenoord, not AZ, but Makkelie and Blank. This is a rare inversion of the normal dynamics of public opinion, and it shows that referees are becoming the central characters of matches in which they should only stand at the margins.

Then there is the role of the media. The very headline of the original article called this a 'major blunder' before the reader had read a single word about the law. That framing shapes the reader's expectation: they enter the article already believing a mistake occurred. It is a familiar pattern, a neutral body with a leading headline. And behind it sits a commercial incentive: controversy generates views, and views generate revenue. The programme 'De Eretribune' itself, with pundits debating each other, is a product sold to an audience.

The last detail I want to keep comes from Kwakman himself. He remarked that Makkelie 'does not think he is happy that he was called to the screen'. That remark, seemingly small, points to a real tension within the system. On-field referees are dragged to the monitor over passages of play sitting on the edge of the threshold, when they are precisely the ones who had the best view in real time. When you repeatedly pull a referee away from his own decision, his trust in his professional instinct is eroded. And a referee who has lost trust in his instinct is a referee who is easily led.

This leads to a consequence few notice. Every time VAR intervenes in a borderline passage of play, it does not merely overturn a decision. It also sends a message to every other referee: that your on-field decision may be reviewed over contacts the naked eye cannot clearly see. Over time, that message can make referees more hesitant in situations that require decisiveness, and hesitation is the enemy of a good referee.

In many countries, associations periodically publish transparency reports on VAR decisions, in which they acknowledge or defend each intervention. If the KNVB does the same, this incident will most likely appear in the next report, and its conclusion will be an indicator of how this association views the intervention threshold. That is why I do not rush to a verdict. I wait for data, not for commentary.

At the European level, controversies like this are quietly pushing football toward automation. Semi-automated offside has become standard in many major leagues, and in-stadium audio, meaning the public broadcast of the exchange between referee and VAR, is being trialled in some places. Every night like the one at Feyenoord is a small data point feeding that process. It shows that when humans are asked to adjudicate subjective contact at high speed, error is unavoidable, and the only thing we can control is the degree of transparency in the process.

I do not believe there is any conspiracy here. I do not believe Makkelie or Blank erred out of malice. I believe something simpler: a system with a vague threshold will produce vague decisions, and vague decisions will always find someone to blame. The vague measure is never put on trial, only the person holding it.

The luck of this trade comes not from being on time, but from being in the right place, and daring to stay longer than anyone else. I stayed with this story longer than a news bulletin, because I believe it is one piece of a larger question waiting for European football to answer. That question is not whether VAR should exist. That question is how far we want VAR to intervene.

If associations begin to reconsider how they summon referees to the monitor, if they make the footage and the intervention standard public, then nights like this can become data instead of argument. If they do not, then every matchday will produce another 'major blunder', and fans will keep learning to trust referees less, not more.

What I want to see in the next match is not a silent VAR, but a VAR brave enough to explain. Because in modern football, silence is no longer neutrality. Silence is a choice, and it always has a price.

Cầu thủ liên quan